About Me
- Sumesh Balakrishnan
- Iam Sumesh Balakrishnan, a Chartered Accountant and Company Secretary presently working with Hitachi Consulting (Formerly Sierra Atlantic) wherein I have worked over last 8 years + in different capacities to head the finance at present.
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Penalty under Service Tax
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Exemption on the right to use packaged or canned software from service tax
Notification No. 17/2010-Service Tax, New Delhi, the 27.02.2010
G.S.R. (E).- In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 93 of the Finance Act, 1994 (32 of 1994), the Central Government, on being satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest so to do, hereby exempts the taxable service providing packaged or canned software, intended for single use and packed accordingly, for the purpose specified in item (v) of clause (zzzze) of sub-section 105 of section 65 of the said Finance Act, from the whole of service tax, subject to the following conditions, namely:-
(i) document providing the right to use such software, by whatever name called, if any, is packed along with the software;
(ii) the importer has paid the appropriate duties of customs on the entire amount received from the buyer; and
(iii) the benefit under notification No. 31/2010– Customs dated the 27th of February, 2010 is not availed of by the importer.
[F. No. 334/1/2010-TRU]
(Prashant Kumar)
Under Secretary to the Government of India
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Service tax on hire purchase, leasing transactions
The petitioners argued that they were non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) and were engaged inter-alia in the business of hire purchase and leasing and that the 46th Amendment to the Constitution of India had inserted Article 366 (29A) in order to deem a set of six transactions enumerated thereunder as constituting a sale of goods and to therefore be chargeable to a sales tax, now VAT. These included the transfer of the right to use of any goods for any purpose as well as hire purchase and leasing transactions. Consequently, the State had imposed a sales tax, now VAT, on the aforesaid transactions and the entire amount paid by the hiree / lessee to the hirer / lessor by way of installments were made chargeable to the VAT. Accordingly, no service element was at all envisaged or involved in these transactions. It was also argued based on the underlying invoices as well as the related documentation that the parties to the contract did not at any time envisage any services to be provided and indeed no charges were collected towards rendition of services. Hence, the extension of the service tax to hire purchase and leasing transactions was violative of various Articles of the Constitution of India.
The appellants relied on several judgements of the Supreme Court including Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited vs. Union of India(2006-TIOL-15-SC-CT-LB), which had held that a particular transaction could not be charged to both the goods tax and the service tax and the test for deciding whether a transaction fell within the ambit of either tax was to determine its substance i.e. its dominant nature. Reliance was also placed on another decision of the Supreme Court in Imagic Creative Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Commercial Tax (2008-TIOL-04-SC-VAT) which had held that service tax and VAT were mutually exclusive and operated in mutual domains.
In addition to the above Supreme Court decisions, reliance was also placed on the recent decision of the Delhi High Court in Home Solution Retail India Ltd vs. Union of India (2009-TIOL-196-HC-DEL-ST), which held that there was no service element in regard to renting of immoveable property and had consequently set aside the charge of service tax on rentals pertaining to letting out of immoveable property on lease.
As opposed to the aforesaid arguments, the state relied on the decisions of the Supreme Court in Tamil Nadu Kalyana Mandapam Association vs. Union of India, (2004-TIOL-36-SC-ST) and in Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. vs Union of India, (2005-TIOL-53-SC-ST) to argue that the levy of service tax on hire purchase / leasing transactions was constitutionally valid and hence the definition of banking and other financial services in service tax law as ‘financial services including equipment leasing and hire purchase’ was entirely proper and legal.
In particular, reliance was placed on the observation of the Supreme Court in the Kalyana Mandapam case (supra) that it was incorrect to argue that the transactions envisaged under Article 366 (29A) could not be charged to a service tax merely on the ground that such transactions were deemed to be sales and charged to the sales tax to the extent that there was a sale of goods, intended or otherwise, in relation to such transactions. Further, the Government had granted a deduction of 90 per cent from the installment amounts and only the balance 10 per cent was charged to the tax.
The Madras High Court took note of these contending arguments and also considered the definition of banking and other financial services as contained in the service tax provisions. It noticed that the appellants had admittedly collected service charge at 1 per cent for preparation of documentation and other incidental activities relating to hire purchase/lease transactions. At the same time, it took note of the argument that the appellants had not charged or recovered any sums towards any service charges as part of the installments for rentals, which was the principal transaction in question.
The High Court thereupon held that the hire purchase and leasing transactions admittedly included the concept of rendering of services. Consequently, the service tax that had been imposed on the transaction in question was constitutionally valid.
The Court appears to have come to this determination perhaps based on the admission of the appellants that they had collected a service charge of 1 per cent with regard to preparation of documents and other incidental activities. This admission was in relation to the aforesaid incidental activities only and was not with regard to the principal activity. Nevertheless, the Court has come to its finding, without a substantive discussion on the point. With regard to the challenge of the appellants that the service tax on hire purchase and leasing transactions was discriminatory in law, the High Court has held that there was no basis for this argument since banking companies, as opposed to the NBFC appellants, were indeed paying service tax on similar transactions of hire purchase and leasing that they were carrying out. Finally, the Court also negated the argument that such a tax restricted the freedom envisaged under Article 19 of the Constitution.
In sum, the High Court has upheld the charge of service tax on hire purchase and leasing transactions, notwithstanding that the same transactions were chargeable to the VAT. This decision in effect upholds the double taxation of the same transaction of hire purchase and leasing to both the service tax as well as the VAT. It remains to be seen whether an appeal would be preferred to the Supreme Court against this decision and what the decision of the Supreme Court would be in regard to such an appeal.
Thursday, July 9, 2009
Imposition of service tax on Builders
F. No. 137/12/2006-CX.4
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise and Customs
***
New Delhi, dated 29th January 2009
Subject: Imposition of service tax on Builders - regarding
************
Construction of residential complex was brought under service tax w.e.f.01.06.2005. Doubts have arisen regarding the applicability of service tax in a case where developer / builder/promoter enters into an agreement, with the ultimate owner for selling a dwelling unit in a residential complex at any stage of construction (or even prior to that) and who makes construction linked payment. The ‘Construction of Complex’ service has been defined under Section 65 (105)(zzzh) of the Finance Act as “any service provided or to be provided to any person, by any other person, in relation to construction of a complex”. The ‘Construction of Complex’ includes construction of a ‘new residential complex’. For this purpose, ‘residential complex’ means any complex of a building or buildings, having more than twelve residential units. A complex constructed by a person directly engaging any other person for designing or planning of the layout, and the construction of such complex intended for personal use as residence by such person has been excluded from the ambit of service tax.
2. A view has been expressed that once an agreement of sale is entered into with the buyer for a unit in a residential complex, he becomes the owner of the residential unit and subsequent activity of a builder for construction of residential unit is a service of ‘construction of residential complex’ to the customer and hence service tax would be applicable to it. A contrary view has been expressed arguing that where a buyer makes construction linked payment after entering into agreement to sell, the nature of transaction is not a service but that of a sale. Where a buyer enters into an agreement to get a fully constructed residential unit, the transaction of sale is completed only after complete construction of the residential unit. Till the completion of the construction activity, the property belongs to the builder or promoter and any service provided by him towards construction is in the nature of self service. It has also been argued that even if it is taken that service is provided to the customer, a single residential unit bought by the individual customer would not fall in the definition of ‘residential complex’ as defined for the purposes of levy of service tax and hence construction of it would not attract service tax.
3. The matter has been examined by the Board. Generally, the initial agreement between the promoters / builders / developers and the ultimate owner is in the nature of ‘agreement to sell’. Such a case, as per the provisions of the Transfer of Property Act, does not by itself create any interest in or charge on such property. The property remains under the ownership of the seller (in the instant case, the promoters/builders/developers). It is only after the completion of the construction and full payment of the agreed sum that a sale deed is executed and only then the ownership of the property gets transferred to the ultimate owner. Therefore, any service provided by such seller in connection with the construction of residential complex till the execution of such sale deed would be in the nature of ‘self-service’ and consequently would not attract service tax. Further, if the ultimate owner enters into a contract for construction of a residential complex with a promoter / builder / developer, who himself provides service of design, planning and construction; and after such construction the ultimate owner receives such property for his personal use, then such activity would not be subjected to service tax, because this case would fall under the exclusion provided in the definition of ‘residential complex’. However, in both these situations, if services of any person like contractor, designer or a similar service provider are received, then such a person would be liable to pay service tax.
4. All pending cases may be disposed of accordingly. Any decision by the Advance Ruling Authority in a specific case, which is contrary to the foregoing views, would have limited application to that case only. In case any difficulty is faced in implementing these instructions, the same may be brought to the notice of the undersigned.
Sunday, June 14, 2009
Service tax on services rendered from outside India
As a consequence, explanation added at the end of section 65(105) of the Act in 2005 was omitted. The new section paves way to the clear legislative intention of the Central Government on the taxation of taxable services rendered by non-resident persons from outside India (i.e., outside the territorial limits of India) to a person in India.
Person Liable
Section 68 of the Act provides for payment of service tax. Accordingly, every person providing taxable service to any person shall pay service tax at the specified rate in prescribed manner. Sub-section (2) provides that Central Government is empowered to notify any taxable service on which service tax shall be paid by such person in prescribed manner as notified and such person shall be the person liable for paying service tax in relation to such service. Notification no. 36/2004-ST as amended by Notification no. 9/2006-ST dated 19/04/2006 notified that service recipient shall be the person liable for any taxable service provided or to be provided from a country other than India and received in India under section 66A of the Act. Rule 2(1)(d) of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 (‘Rules’) prescribe person liable for paying service tax. According to clause (iv), taxable service received from a non resident were taxable in India in the hands of the recipient receiving such taxable service in India. W.e.f. 19.4.2006, the recipient of service has been made the person liable in relation to any taxable service provided to be provided by any person from a country other than India and received by any person in India.
Judicial View
In the case of Aditya Cement vs. CCE, Jaipur II - 2007-TIOL-236-CESTAT-DEL, it has been held that Rule 2(1)(d)(iv) of the Rules only defines the person liable to pay service tax and cannot shift the liability on the person other than service provider unless proper notification is issued under section 68(2) of the Act. In the instant case, Rule 2(1)(d)(iv) of the Rules was examined with reference to Notification no. 36/2004-ST.
In another case of Molex (India) Ltd. vs. CCE (Appeals), Bangalore – 2007-TIOL-2305-CESTAT-BANG, it was held that question of leviability of service tax on the service recipient prior to 1.1.2005 has to be decided by a larger bench in view o f the conflicting decisions on the matter. As noted above, in the case of Aditya Cement (supra), it was held that service tax liability on recipient in case of import of service is only w.e.f 1.1.2005 in view of Notification no. 36/2004-ST and that the rules are subservient to the sections and if a section do not provide discharge of service tax liability by recipient of services from non-resident having no office, then it would be futile exercise to rely upon rules to collect the tax. (This was further followed by Ispat Industries Ltd. vs. CCE, Raigad – 2007-TIOL-399-CESTAT-MUM.In other case of Calvin Wooding Consulting Ltd. vs. CCE, Indore – 2007-TIOL-670-CESTAT-DEL, contrary view was taken that the liability to pay service tax for the services received from abroad is on the recipient [Also see Samcor Glass Ltd. vs. CCE, Jaipur 1 – 2007-TIOL-938-CESTAT-DEL]
In CCE vs. Rainbow Denim Ltd. – 2009-TIOL-389-CESTAT-DEL it was held that where service was provided by a non resident from outside India who does not have any office in India, having been specified as taxable service w.e.f. 1/1/2005 under Notification no. 36/2004-ST, receipt of such service could not be held liable for paying service tax prior to 1/1/2005.
In BHEL vs, CCE – 2009-TIOL-634-CESTAT-DEL, it was held that where service is provided by foreign companies who have no office in India, demand of service tax form service recipient is not sustainable for the period prior to 1/1/2005.
In Hindustan Zinc Ltd. vs. CCE, Jaipur – 2008-TIOL-1149-CESTAT-DEL-LB, larger bench observed that levy of service tax is on rendering to taxable service and not on person. Definition clause can not be read as substantive. The manner of collection of tax is not extendable to include person liable to pay service tax. It was held that service recipient of consulting engineering service provided from outside India was not liable to pay service tax prior to 1/1/2005. Since the liability to pay service tax is generally on the provider of service, where liability is to be fastened on any other person, the services in relation to which liability is to be so fastened, has also to be identified and specified. The services were notified w.e.f. 1/1/2005 vide Notification no. 36/2004-ST.
Section 66A
The Finance Act, 2006 inserted section 66A to levy service tax under reverse charge method on taxable services provided from outside India to a recipient in India. At the same time, explanation at the end of sub section (105) of section 65 of the Act as inserted in 2005 was omitted which also provided for the similar provision.
Section 66A applies to specific situation where any taxable service specified in section 65(105) is provided by a person from outside India and received by a person in India and in such situation, section 66 does not apply. In case of deemed import of services, section 66A becomes the charging section instead of section 66. Thus, these two section are mutually exclusive.
Section 66A of the Act imposes two conditions which needs to be satisfied for taxation of service tax on such imported services -
— service must be received by a person in India
— service provider must be situated outside India.
If both the above conditions are fulfilled, then only the question of levy of service tax arises. Import of services not meant for commercial use or business use shall not be taxable.
From When Liable - Judicial View
In a very recent case of Indian National Ship Owners Association vs. UOI – 2009 TIOL 150 HC MUM ST, the High Court held that -
(a) Notification no. 1/2002-ST dated 1/3/2002 does not levy service tax on the service recipient.
(b) Rule 2(1)(d)(iv) of the Rules does not apply to levy of service tax on services rendered from outside India .
(c) Service recipient can not be made liable to pay service tax under Rule 2(1)(d)(iv) unless there is a provision in the Act.
(d) For services received outside India, Rule 2(1)(d)(iv) would not apply as service were received by assessee outside India and not in India.
(e) W.e.f. 18.4.2006, vide section 66A, a persons resident in India or having business in India has been made liable to service tax as a recipient of service outside India.
(f) Members of petitioner association receiving various services outside India from non- residents were not liable to service tax period prior to 18/4/2006.
The court observed that vide notification no. 1/2002 (supra) service which is rendered or provided in the Continental Shelf Exclusive Economic Zone and Territorial Waters of India has been made taxable that notification does not have the effect of levying service tax on the recipients of the service. Therefore, levy of service tax on the members of the petitioners association on the basis of notification dated 1st March, 2002 is plainly without authority of law.
Where the vessels and ships owned by members of petitioner association received service outside India, court observed tax service tax can not be levied on the basis of Rule 2(1)(d)(iv) of the Rules.
Because of the enactment of section 66A of the Act, a person who is resident in India or business in India becomes liable to be levied service tax when he receives service outside India. From section 66A it is apparent that there was no authority vested by law in the respondents to levy service tax on a person who is resident in India, but who receives service outside India. In that case till section 66A was enacted a person liable was the one who rendered the service. In other words, it is only after enactment of section 66A that taxable services received from abroad by a person belonging to India are taxed in the hands of the Indian residents. In such cases, the Indian recipient of the taxable services is deemed to be a service provider. Before enactment of section there was no such provision in the Act and therefore, the respondents had no authority to levy service tax on the members of the petitioners association. In the ultimate analysis, court held that assessees, members of Ship owners Association receiving various service outside India from non resident were not liable to service tax for the period form 1st March, 2002 to 17th April 2006.
In the case of Malwa Cotton Spinning Mills vs. CCE – 2009-TIOL-185-CESTAT-DEL it was held that services rendered by non resident from outside India is not a taxable service for the period prior to insertion of section 66A w.e.f. 18.4.2006.
Conclusion
Based on the statutory provisions and judicial pronouncements, following position emerges -
(i) Levy of service tax is on rendering of taxable service and not on person.
(ii) No service tax is leviable on services received from abroad prior to 1/1/2005.
(iii) Receipt of taxable services from abroad from service providers not having office in India is taxable w.e.f. 1/1/2005.
(iv) Taxable services rendered is India by a service provider from outside India shall be taxed in India under section 66A of the Act w.e.f. 18/4/2006 and service receiver shall be liable to pay service tax under reverse charge method.